COVID-19 power shift: Experts have ‘deep worries’ about sidelined CDC

COVID-19 power shift: Experts have ‘deep worries’ about sidelined CDC
The Trump administration has taken control of COVID-19 data in the United States, leaving public health experts gravely concerned about whether anyone outside of the administration will be able to access the vital information moving forward.

Such data is critical for health systems to plan for necessary resources and coordinate efforts, particularly during a pandemic.

Full coverage of the coronavirus outbreak

“Whoever controls the data is in the driver’s seat. They have the power,” said Dr. Christopher Ohl, a professor of infectious diseases at Wake Forest Baptist Health in Winston-Salem, North Carolina.

“I’m concerned that we’ll only get what their analyses and conclusions are, and there won’t be any way to corroborate it,” Ohl said.

Late Tuesday, a spokesman for the Department of Health and Human Services confirmed to NBC News that hospitals are now required to submit information on COVID-19 patients directly to HHS, rather than through a long-standing reporting system via the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Let our news meet your inbox. The news and stories that matters, delivered weekday mornings.

“The new faster and complete data system is what our nation needs to defeat the coronavirus and the CDC, an operating division of HHS, will certainly participate in this streamlined all-of-government response,” Michael Caputo, assistant secretary for public affairs at HHS, said in a statement Tuesday. “They will simply no longer control it.”

Dr. Robert Redfield, the director of the CDC, said Wednesday that his agency will still play a role within the new reporting system.

“No one has taken access or data away from CDC,” Redfield said at a press briefing, insisting the change would help to “dramatically improve and modernize our public health data in America.”

“I fully support an effort to try to improve upon existing approaches,” Jennifer Nuzzo, a senior scholar at the Johns Hopkins Center for Health Security, said. “That said, I have deep worries about switching it up in the middle of a crisis, particularly if it means sidelining the CDC.”

José Arrieta, chief information officer for HHS, said the agency is “exploring the best way to make this information available to the public,” but both he and Redfield declined to offer a timeline for when that would happen.

“For the data to be valuable, it needs to be trusted. And that’s really where transparency comes into play,” Nuzzo said. “People have to be able to scrutinize the data to understand the process by which they are generated and be able to see the strengths and weaknesses.”

Download the NBC News app for full coverage of the coronavirus outbreak

Ohl said the previous reporting system within the CDC, called the National Health Safety Network, has been in operation for years. “All of the kinks are worked out,” he said. “It’s reliable, sound, unbiased.”

It remained unclear how hospitals — already strapped for resources — would be able to pivot effectively to a new reporting system during the pandemic.

The switch comes as cases of the coronavirus are soaring nationwide, accelerating rapidly during the month of July. States particularly affected are Arizona, California, Florida and Texas, with daily case counts breaking records in recent days.

Ohl said such a change is unprecedented. “It just doesn’t make sense.”

Follow NBC HEALTH on Twitter & Facebook.

Image: Erika EdwardsErika Edwards

Erika Edwards is a health and medical news writer and reporter for NBC News and “TODAY.”

XL subscribe to our newsletter banner

Get the latest news and advice on COVID-19, direct from the experts in your inbox. Join hundreds of thousands who trust experts by subscribing to our newsletter.

Send your news and stories to us or and WhatsApp: +447747873668.

Before you go...

Democratic norms are being stress-tested all over the world, and the past few years have thrown up all kinds of questions we didn't know needed clarifying – how long is too long for a parliamentary prorogation? How far should politicians be allowed to intervene in court cases? To monitor these issues as closely as we have in the past we need your support, so please consider donating to The Climax News Room.